我比咗 DVD 佢啦         

They didn't say what exactly does it mean by "moving the island".  So instead of taking a wild guess, I patiently waited for Season 5.


Now it makes sense why only 6 survivors have left the island!  The rest did not die (some did, on the boat), they were "moved" with the island!!!!  At that point i was guessing that the island was moved to a different location.  Remember how the polar bear showed up on the island?  It seems like things can be moved from one location to another.


I forgot... what had happened to Claire in the jungle???  Can you refresh my memory?


Michael's death was not too disappointing.  But Jin's death was kind of sad!!


That's another scene that blew my mind!!  And imagined when Minnie and I watched it, we had to wait for half a year to see season 5!!!  To answer your question, my guess was that John was using a fake name because he wasn't one of the 6 survivors of Oceanic 815 who were known to the world. To the outside world, he was dead in the crash.  He somehow escaped from the island (which was a total surprise to me) and he could not use his real identity.  Second guess was that he was not John, he was Jeremy Bentham.  But I had not idea who that was.    If my first guess was right, then the questions are: 1) how did he escape?  2) how did he die?

In the flashfoward in last episode of Season 3 when Kate and Jack met at night, didn't they mention the name "Jeremy Bentham"??

Finally....i read all the questions.  First, i have to say sorry that I haven't chase you guys' speed   And I will start Season 5 ASAP.

I just wonder....should we count Aaron as the 6 survivor?  Because when the plane crashed.....Aaron's wasn't born yet.  And his name is not on the passenger list.  So.....can we count him as a survivor?

That's true.  Officially arron is not considered a survivor.  But technically he was inside Claire's tummy, so he was on the plane when it crashed.    I guess the media just counted him as one of the survivors so they reported "the six survivors from Oceanic 815 crash".

Hmm....if Aaron is one of the oceanic 6.  if we prefer Oceanic 6 aree Jack, Kate, Hurley, Sayid, Aaron,  and Sun.  Then how can John back to the world and sleep in the coffin?

The other things which confuse me is in Season 4 Episode 7 too.  Sun is having a baby in hospital.  But Jin went to visit another person in hosptial and mentioned he just got married for 2 months.  So....is that mean there have 2 Sun in the world or his wife is not Sun?  By the way...Jin should be dead......Does the Oceanic 6 change the history after they come back?  That's why Ben said they must back to the island.....?

ben, that's true!  so maybe John was one of them!  But John was not rescued along with Jack and the rest... so there is a disconnection.   Oh, maybe John was rescued separately!

No, Jin was not visiting his own baby, he was visiting his boss's baby I think.

And that was not flashforward, that was flashback of the younger Jin buying the doll for his boss baby.  The writer purposely show those two stories to mislead audience

Ok i see.  I wonder what causes Jack really want to back to island?